Posted in

“CAN THEY AFFORD THE C.A.R?” — The household budget that turned an electric-vehicle debate into a question about working families..-tete

John Kennedy had listened to Pete Buttigieg discuss the future of American transportation when he reached into his jacket pocket and removed an ordinary car key.

He placed it on the desk.

No one paid much attention.

Not at first.

The Louisiana senator opened a folder and studied a page of handwritten figures.

Rent.

Groceries.

Utilities.

Insurance.

Car payments.

And the amount of money a working American had left after taxes.

Then he looked toward the former transportation secretary, appearing in this imagined congressional policy hearing to discuss the transportation decisions made during the Biden administration.

This Freshman GOP Senator Could Defy Wall Street - Bloomberg

“Mr. Secretary, I want to talk about something a little less complicated than national energy policy.”

Buttigieg nodded.

“Of course, Senator.”

Kennedy adjusted his glasses.

“Let’s talk about whether somebody can afford to get to work.”

The room became quiet.

Buttigieg began explaining that electric vehicles could reduce fuel and maintenance expenses over time, depending on the vehicle and the driver’s circumstances.

Kennedy nodded.

“I understand the argument.”

He paused.

“Electricity can cost less than gasoline.”

“That’s right,” Buttigieg answered.

“And an electric motor can require less routine maintenance.”

“Yes.”

Kennedy looked at his notes.

“But if a fellow doesn’t have enough money to buy the vehicle in the first place, those savings aren’t doing him much good, are they?”

Buttigieg acknowledged the affordability challenge.

Kennedy leaned forward.

“Then let’s talk about that.”

He turned over the first page.

At the top was a hypothetical electric vehicle.

Purchase price: $65,000.

The senator pointed toward it.

“Suppose someone recommends a vehicle like this to an American family struggling with gas prices.”

Buttigieg immediately clarified that he had not told every American to purchase a $65,000 electric vehicle.

Kennedy nodded.

“Fair enough.”

He paused.

“Then we’ll treat it as an example, not your personal recommendation.”

The former secretary agreed.

Kennedy continued.

Pete Buttigieg: 'Of course' America is ready for a gay prez | Out.com

“Because I want to know whether a family with a very ordinary paycheck could make these numbers work.”

He lifted his pencil.

“And I don’t think we need a Ph.D. to figure it out.”

The confrontation had begun.

The central disagreement was not whether electric vehicles could reduce gasoline consumption.

Both men understood that they could.

It was whether the financial advantages of electric transportation were accessible to the people who faced the greatest pressure from rising living costs.

Kennedy wanted to examine the household budget before discussing the long-term benefits of a technological transition.

Buttigieg wanted to distinguish the price of a particular expensive vehicle from the wider market for electric cars.

Both questions mattered.

But for a family living from paycheck to paycheck, the order in which they were answered could make all the difference.

The backdrop to the exchange was a real controversy from 2022.

As gasoline prices rose, the Biden administration emphasized electric vehicles as part of its strategy for transportation, energy security, and lower long-term driving costs.

Buttigieg argued that EV ownership could protect drivers from fluctuations at the gasoline pump.

Critics said the argument risked overlooking how expensive electric vehicles were to purchase.

The dispute intensified during a July 19, 2022, hearing of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

Republican Representative Scott Perry challenged Buttigieg about EV affordability.

Perry cited an average price around $55,000 and argued that electric vehicles were beyond the financial reach of many Americans.

Buttigieg responded that the market included substantially cheaper models.

He cited the Chevrolet Bolt, then advertised at approximately $26,595.

He also acknowledged that many Americans could not easily afford electric vehicles.

That exchange did not involve Kennedy.

But it captured a real policy disagreement.

The cost of owning a vehicle included more than the price paid at a dealership.

And the affordability of an electric vehicle depended on which model a family considered, how it was financed, where it was charged, and how much it was driven.

Kennedy, in the dramatized hearing, wanted to push the argument further.

He looked toward Buttigieg.

“Mr. Secretary, when people talk about an expensive vehicle saving them money on gasoline, I sometimes wonder whether they’ve looked at the price of the car.”

United States Senator John Neely Kennedy – Ảnh báo chí có sẵn – Ảnh có sẵn  | Shutterstock Editorial

Buttigieg nodded.

“That’s why I’ve argued that affordability and lower-cost options matter.”

Kennedy acknowledged the answer.

“Good.”

Then he pointed toward the $65,000 figure.

“Let’s use a high-priced example and see how difficult the math can become.”

He turned toward the committee staff.

“Put the numbers on the screen, please.”

A chart appeared.

The vehicle cost $65,000.

The hypothetical buyer made a 10 percent down payment.

That required $6,500 in cash.

The remaining principal was $58,500.

If financed for six years at an illustrative annual interest rate of 7 percent, the monthly loan payment would be approximately $997.

Kennedy looked toward Buttigieg.

“That’s almost a thousand dollars a month.”

Buttigieg nodded.

“For that example, yes.”

“And that’s before insurance.”

“Correct.”

“Before charging.”

“Yes.”

“And before any unexpected expenses.”

“Correct.”

Kennedy placed the pencil on his notes.

“Then a family doesn’t have a thousand-dollar-a-month transportation budget merely because somebody promises they’ll save money at the gas station.”

The room was quiet.

Buttigieg responded that no responsible affordability analysis would focus exclusively on a $65,000 vehicle.

He emphasized that buyers could consider lower-priced models, used vehicles, incentives where eligible, and financing terms appropriate to their finances.

Kennedy nodded.

“That’s a fair response.”

Then he asked:

“But can we agree that the gasoline savings don’t erase the monthly payment?”

Buttigieg answered that vehicle costs needed to be evaluated together.

Kennedy pointed toward the chart.

“Then let’s put everything together.”

He moved to the second page.

Can a Democrat become Mississippi's next senator? Pete Buttigieg thinks so.

This time, the heading read:

A WORKING FAMILY’S MONTHLY BUDGET.

Kennedy described a hypothetical household receiving $3,600 in monthly take-home pay.

It was not a claim about the national median income.

It was an illustrative budget designed to test a particular financial decision.

The family paid $1,600 in rent.

Groceries cost $650.

Utilities and phone service cost $300.

Basic household, health, and child-related expenses required another $350.

Before transportation, the family had already committed $2,900 of its $3,600 income.

That left $700.

Kennedy looked toward Buttigieg.

“Seven hundred dollars.”

The former secretary nodded.

“Under your assumptions.”

“Exactly.”

Kennedy paused.

“Now put a thousand-dollar car payment in that budget.”

The room became still.

The calculation produced a deficit before car insurance or charging.

Kennedy tapped the page.

“We’re already short, and we haven’t turned the key.”

Buttigieg responded that the example demonstrated why the family should not buy a vehicle at that price.

Kennedy nodded.

“That’s exactly what it demonstrates.”

The former secretary continued.

“The question is whether more affordable electric options can provide savings compared with gasoline vehicles at comparable prices.”

Kennedy acknowledged the distinction.

Then he leaned forward.

“Now we’re discussing something useful.”

The exchange had moved away from an accusation about one supposed quote.

It had become a more serious discussion about the difference between lower operating costs and the ability to finance a purchase.

For many households, transportation was not simply a consumer preference.

It was necessary for employment.

A worker might need a car to reach a warehouse before sunrise.

A nurse might travel between shifts when buses were unavailable.

A parent might drive children to school before going to work.

In some communities, public transportation offered a practical alternative.

In others, owning a vehicle was nearly unavoidable.

That dependence made the price of transportation economically important.

But it also made replacing an existing vehicle a difficult decision.

A family with a reliable paid-off gasoline car might spend more on fuel than an EV owner.

But it might have no monthly car loan.

Replacing that vehicle could introduce a large new expense even if the cost of energy per mile declined.

Kennedy turned to that distinction.

“Mr. Secretary, suppose our family already owns a ten-year-old car.”

Buttigieg nodded.

“It runs.”

“Yes.”

“It’s paid for.”

“Yes.”

“And the family spends money on gas and repairs.”

“Of course.”

Kennedy leaned forward.

“Then the financially sensible decision may be to keep that car running rather than take on a large new loan.”

Buttigieg agreed that replacement decisions depended on the condition of the existing car, expected repairs, financing, and other circumstances.

Kennedy nodded.

“That’s the point.”

He paused.

“The cheapest mile isn’t always driven by the car with the newest technology. Sometimes it’s driven by the car the family already owns.”

The room became quiet.

Buttigieg responded that electric vehicles could still offer meaningful economic benefits, particularly for high-mileage drivers.

Kennedy acknowledged that.

He did not dispute that energy costs could differ substantially between gasoline and electric vehicles.

Instead, he wanted to know how consumers could access those benefits without taking on financial obligations beyond their means.

The former secretary described the importance of less expensive EV models.

He discussed competition among automakers.

He emphasized that greater production could improve choice and reduce prices over time.

And he referred to the need for charging infrastructure.

Kennedy listened.

Then he changed the subject to renters.

“Mr. Secretary, where does a family living in an apartment charge an electric vehicle?”

Buttigieg answered that options could include workplace charging, public charging stations, and facilities installed at multifamily buildings.

Kennedy nodded.

“But not every apartment has a charger.”

“That’s true.”

“And not every tenant can install one.”

“Correct.”

“Some people have to use public fast chargers.”

“Yes.”

Kennedy looked down.

“And public charging can cost more than plugging in at home.”

Buttigieg acknowledged that charging costs varied.

Kennedy continued.

“So the family we described may face a higher vehicle payment and may not get the cheapest electricity price either.”

The room remained quiet.

Buttigieg responded that those barriers were among the reasons federal and state governments had supported charging infrastructure.

He argued that expanding access could make electric vehicles practical for more households.

Kennedy nodded.

“Then we should judge whether those investments actually reach the people who need them.”

The disagreement shifted toward government policy.

Supporters of federal EV incentives argued that early investment could help develop a larger, more competitive market.

They emphasized energy security, lower emissions, technological innovation, and potential savings for consumers.

Critics questioned whether the benefits were distributed fairly.

Some argued that subsidies could favor households wealthy enough to buy new vehicles.

Others raised concerns about charging access, battery supply chains, and the costs imposed on taxpayers.

The senator from Louisiana wanted to evaluate the transition through the experience of a lower-income household.

Buttigieg wanted to explain that a transportation policy could improve affordability over time even if some products remained expensive in the present.

Kennedy returned to the budget.

“Mr. Secretary, I understand long-term plans.”

He paused.

“I understand investments.”

“And I understand that new technologies can become cheaper.”

Then he held up the page.

“But rent is due this month. Groceries have to be bought this week. And the car has to start tomorrow morning.”

The room fell silent.

Buttigieg answered that immediate affordability was a legitimate concern and that the government also needed to address the future cost of transportation.

Kennedy acknowledged that broader perspective.

Then he asked how policymakers should measure success.

Was it the number of electric vehicles sold?

The amount of charging infrastructure installed?

The average purchase price?

Or the number of households that could obtain reliable transportation without excessive financial strain?

Buttigieg argued that all of those measures could contribute to evaluating policy.

Kennedy nodded.

“Then let’s not mistake one for another.”

He paused.

“A rising number of expensive vehicles sold doesn’t necessarily tell us whether an ordinary family can afford to replace a broken car.”

The former secretary agreed that sales figures alone did not provide a complete picture of affordability.

The moderator looked toward the clock.

But Kennedy had another question.

He asked about the relationship between purchase price and lifetime ownership costs.

Buttigieg explained that electric cars typically avoided gasoline purchases and could require less routine maintenance.

Depending on the model and charging arrangement, these benefits could offset some of the higher initial purchase price.

Kennedy acknowledged the analysis.

Then he introduced a second hypothetical.

Two vehicles.

One gasoline-powered.

One electric.

Both comparably equipped and both reasonably practical for the same driver.

If their purchase prices were similar, the electric model might be financially attractive over time.

But if the EV cost thousands more upfront, the buyer would need to examine whether energy and maintenance savings outweighed the difference.

Financing costs could alter the result.

So could annual mileage.

Insurance.

Depreciation.

Repair expenses.

Local gasoline and electricity prices.

And the availability of charging.

Kennedy looked toward Buttigieg.

“That’s a lot more complicated than telling someone they’ll stop paying for gasoline.”

Buttigieg nodded.

“That’s why consumers need accurate information about total ownership costs.”

Kennedy smiled faintly.

“Now there’s something we can agree on.”

The room relaxed for a moment.

Then the senator continued.

“Let me ask you this.”

He paused.

“Is a $26,000 electric car more affordable than a $65,000 electric car?”

Buttigieg smiled.

“Obviously, all else being equal.”

Kennedy nodded.

“Good.”

“But a $26,000 vehicle may still be too expensive for a family with almost no money left after essentials.”

Buttigieg agreed.

Kennedy pointed toward the household budget.

“Then affordability is not a slogan. It’s the relationship between the price and the money people actually have available.”

The former secretary emphasized the value of used electric vehicles and broader market development.

Kennedy acknowledged those possibilities.

But he raised another concern.

A family buying a used EV needed reliable information about battery condition, expected range, repair costs, and charging access.

A family buying a used gasoline car also needed information about engine condition and mechanical reliability.

Both decisions involved risk.

The senator argued that policymakers should avoid oversimplifying either option.

Buttigieg agreed that accurate consumer information mattered.

The confrontation had taken a quieter turn.

Neither man was arguing that every American should drive the same kind of vehicle.

Nor had anyone demonstrated that every EV was unaffordable.

The real disagreement concerned which households could benefit immediately and what government should do to expand their options.

Then Kennedy reached the final page of his folder.

He looked toward the small object he had placed on the desk at the beginning.

The car key.

It was old.

The metal had lost some of its shine.

The plastic casing was scratched.

A faded rubber tag hung from the key ring.

Kennedy picked it up.

He held it between two fingers.

“Mr. Secretary, you know what this is?”

Buttigieg looked toward it.

“A car key.”

Kennedy nodded.

“That’s right.”

He placed it on the table between them.

“It’s not a fancy thing.”

A pause.

“It’s not an economic projection.”

“It’s not a climate model.”

“And it doesn’t require a federal grant to understand.”

The room grew quiet.

Kennedy pointed toward the key.

“For somebody working an early shift, this might be the difference between showing up for work and losing a day’s pay.”

Buttigieg nodded.

“Reliable transportation is essential.”

Kennedy continued.

“Suppose the person who owns this key drives an old car worth $4,000.”

He paused.

“The car isn’t pretty.”

“It has a few dents.”

“And the air conditioner may not work as well as it used to.”

Then he looked toward the former secretary.

“But it gets the owner to work.”

Buttigieg acknowledged the value of reliable transportation.

Kennedy nodded.

“Now suppose that person spends $180 a month on gas.”

He paused.

“Would it make financial sense to replace the paid-off car with a vehicle that costs nearly $1,000 a month to finance, just to avoid the gasoline bill?”

Buttigieg answered that, under those assumptions, it would not be a sound financial recommendation.

The room became quiet.

Kennedy nodded.

“That’s what I wanted to establish.”

He slid the key slowly across the table.

Then delivered the final question.

“Mr. Secretary, before Washington tells that worker what kind of car to drive, shouldn’t we first ask whether the worker can afford to replace the one this key already starts?”

The room remained silent.

Buttigieg looked toward the key.

Then he answered that affordability, reliability, and consumer choice should be central to transportation policy.

Kennedy nodded.

“Then we’re talking about the same person.”

The moment was deliberately simple.

It did not involve a confidential government document.

No hidden statistic suddenly appeared.

There was no accusation that Buttigieg had committed a crime.

And the senator had not proved that electric vehicles were economically inferior in every circumstance.

The key was a physical reminder of the household constraint that had driven his questions.

For someone who already owned a working vehicle, avoiding a new loan could be more important than reducing the cost of fuel.

For someone shopping for a replacement, a lower-priced electric vehicle might be a practical alternative.

And for a driver covering substantial mileage with affordable home charging, an EV could provide meaningful savings.

All three conclusions could be true.

The circumstances mattered.

The senator continued with one final observation.

“Mr. Secretary, I don’t have anything against innovation.”

He paused.

“I don’t have anything against somebody who wants to buy an electric car.”

Another pause.

“And I certainly don’t have anything against saving money on fuel.”

Then he pointed toward the household budget.

“What bothers me is when our public discussion gets so far above people’s heads that we forget what’s left in their checking accounts.”

Buttigieg responded that expanding affordable transportation choices was an important public objective.

He emphasized that the administration’s investments had been intended to increase availability and reduce long-term costs.

Kennedy acknowledged the stated goal.

Then he asked that policymakers measure progress by affordability in practice, not merely technological ambition.

The moderator called time.

Kennedy gathered his papers.

But he left the key on the desk for a moment.

The former secretary’s argument remained part of the record.

Electric vehicles could provide savings in fuel and maintenance.

Their economics could improve as prices declined and charging networks expanded.

The government could influence market development through infrastructure and incentives.

But Kennedy’s household example raised a different issue.

Families could not spend lifetime savings before they had the money to finance a purchase.

A vehicle might be cheaper to operate over ten years and still be unaffordable to buy today.

That gap between long-term value and immediate affordability was central to the dispute.

It also illustrated why vehicle prices could not be evaluated in isolation.

A family with low rent, significant savings, and access to inexpensive charging might make one decision.

A family facing high rent, little savings, and no home charger might make another.

A rural worker driving many miles each day could have different priorities from an urban resident who rarely drove.

Transportation policy needed to account for those differences.

After the hearing, a reporter approached Kennedy.

“Senator, are you opposed to electric vehicles?”

Kennedy shook his head.

“No.”

The reporter pressed.

“Then what was your point?”

Kennedy held up the key.

“That people have to live within their means.”

He paused.

“And some of those means are mighty limited.”

Another reporter approached Buttigieg.

“Do you believe the senator raised a fair affordability concern?”

The former secretary acknowledged that high vehicle prices remained a significant barrier for many households.

He emphasized that cheaper models, used EVs, and improved charging infrastructure could help address the problem.

The reporter asked whether it made sense for every family to replace a working gasoline car immediately.

Buttigieg answered that vehicle purchasing decisions depended on the individual’s circumstances.

The exchange ended without a finding that the secretary had told struggling Americans to purchase a $65,000 vehicle.

The real historical record did not support that alleged direct instruction.

But the imagined hearing had captured a genuine policy question that had surfaced repeatedly during debates over gasoline prices and the transition to electric transportation.

What does affordability mean to a family living on a limited monthly budget?

For transportation officials, it could involve long-term operating costs, new technology, and the development of a more competitive market.

For a household deciding whether to buy a car, it could involve the down payment, monthly loan, insurance, access to charging, and the risk of unexpected repairs.

Neither perspective was irrelevant.

But neither could replace the other.

The financial example showed why.

A $65,000 car financed with a $58,500 loan could require a monthly payment close to $1,000 under the illustrative terms used.

A household with only $700 left after essential expenses could not make that purchase comfortably.

No amount of projected gasoline savings changed the fact that the loan payment alone exceeded the remaining budget.

At the same time, that example did not establish that every EV cost $65,000.

It did not establish that all gasoline vehicles were cheaper to own.

And it did not eliminate the possibility that a lower-cost EV could be advantageous for a different buyer.

The question was which option actually fitted the household.

That was where Kennedy’s old car key became meaningful.

It represented practical transportation rather than technological preference.

A vehicle that started every morning.

A worker who depended on it.

And a family trying to make it through another month without falling behind.

Kennedy picked up the key before leaving.

He looked once more toward the calculations.

Then he made his final point.

“The best vehicle for a working family isn’t automatically the newest car, the most expensive car, or the car Washington likes best. It’s the one that gets them where they need to go without taking away the money they need to live.”

The hearing ended.

The budget remained on the screen.

Rent.

Groceries.

Utilities.

And the cost of transportation.

The political argument had begun with electric vehicles.

It ended with the realities of household finances.

Before promising a family that a different car will save money, policymakers need to answer the question that comes first: can the family afford the car at all?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *