JOHN KENNED.Y CONFRONTS LAW PROFESSOR OVER SUPREME COURT REMARKS — DICK DURBI.N STEPS IN AS THE HEARING TAKES AN UNEXPECTED TURN
The atmosphere inside the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing room was already tense when Senator John Kennedy turned toward law professor Kate Shaw and opened a folder containing her previous public statements.
He wasn’t interested in another general discussion about judicial independence.
He wanted an explanation.
Across the room, members of the committee watched as Kennedy prepared to question the professor about comments she had made on a political and legal podcast.
Dick Durbin was also present, serving as the committee’s ranking Democratic member.

The hearing concerned the role of federal courts in the constitutional system, including questions about judicial authority, nationwide injunctions, and the relationship between the executive and judicial branches.
But Kennedy was about to take the discussion in a more personal direction.
“Professor Shaw, let me ask you something,” he began.
Shaw looked toward him.
“On April 22, 2024, you said there were some members of the United States Supreme Court who were evil. Which justices were you talking about?”
Shaw appeared uncertain about the quotation.
“I’ll take your word for it, Senator. I don’t recall using that word.”
Kennedy immediately opened his folder.
“All right. Here’s what you said.”
He began reading from the published podcast transcript.
“You were talking about the majority opinion in Muldrow v. City of St. Louis. You said, and I quote: ‘Justice Kagan, I mean, will she be able to control its potential future distortion by her evil colleagues? Probably not.’”
He looked up.
“Who were you talking about?”
Shaw responded cautiously.
“Sir, I’m very skeptical. If that was a transcription, it was probably a transcription error. I do not think I said that.”
Kennedy didn’t let the answer pass.
“No, you said it.”
Shaw attempted to clarify her recollection.
“I would have to refresh my recollection. I’ve been very critical of some members of the Supreme Court.”
Kennedy leaned toward his microphone.
“You’re embarrassed that you made that statement, aren’t you? You’re an officer of the court.”
Shaw replied that the language didn’t sound like something she would ordinarily say.
Then Kennedy delivered the sentence that would become the defining moment of the exchange.
“You know what I’m embarrassed at? That you’re teaching our kids!”
The room suddenly became more attentive.
Shaw immediately pushed back.
“I don’t refer to Supreme Court justices as evil—”
Kennedy interrupted.
“You did right here.”
“In the classroom, sir?”
“On your podcast! April 22, 2024!”
The senator raised his voice slightly as he emphasized the date.
“Big as Dallas!”
The exchange had moved beyond the original question about judicial authority.
Kennedy was now challenging the distinction between Shaw’s responsibilities as a law professor and her public commentary about the nation’s highest court.
He continued.
“And you’re an officer of the court. You’re here advising us to be respectful of federal judges. And you say they’re evil members of the United States Supreme Court?”
He paused.
“Gag me with a spoon. You’re part of the problem in all of this.”
The criticism was unmistakable.
But Shaw’s position raised another issue: whether public criticism of judicial decisions should be treated differently when it comes from someone who teaches constitutional law.
The professor had not argued that judges were exempt from criticism. Her podcast comments concerned the potential treatment of a Supreme Court opinion by other justices.
Kennedy, however, was challenging the language she had used and whether it was consistent with the respect for judicial institutions being discussed during the hearing.
The exchange ended with Kennedy yielding the floor.
And that was when Dick Durbin entered the conversation.
“Thank you, Senator Kennedy,” said Chairman Ted Cruz.
Durbin was recognized.

Rather than continuing Kennedy’s personal confrontation with Shaw, the Illinois senator shifted the discussion toward a constitutional hypothetical raised by Justice Sonia Sotomayor during oral arguments concerning birthright citizenship.
He began explaining a hypothetical scenario involving a new president who might attempt to use executive power to seize firearms nationwide.
The purpose was to examine the limits of presidential authority and the role of federal courts in reviewing executive action.
Durbin’s intervention redirected the hearing toward constitutional principles rather than the professor’s podcast language.
But the contrast between the two exchanges was striking.
Kennedy had focused on the responsibility of legal academics to speak carefully about judges and the judiciary.
Durbin focused on the responsibility of courts to restrain executive power when constitutional limits were potentially at stake.
Two senators.
Two different approaches.
And one hearing that exposed how deeply divided Washington remained over the meaning of judicial independence.
Kennedy’s questioning had raised a difficult issue for legal educators.
Should professors who teach future lawyers and judges be held to a particularly demanding standard when discussing the Supreme Court?
Or should their academic credentials make no difference to their right to criticize judicial decisions in strong language?
That distinction matters.
Universities are places where controversial legal arguments should be examined, challenged, and debated. A professor’s criticism of a judicial opinion is not automatically evidence of professional misconduct.
At the same time, legal educators influence students who will eventually work within the very institutions they discuss.
The question of professional responsibility therefore deserves serious consideration.
Kennedy appeared to believe that Shaw’s description of Supreme Court justices as evil undermined the respect for judicial institutions that legal professionals should encourage.
Shaw’s response suggested that she did not recall using the precise language and questioned whether the transcript accurately reflected her remarks.
The podcast recording and transcript became central to the confrontation.
The senator was not simply asking whether she agreed with particular Supreme Court decisions.
He wanted her to acknowledge the words attributed to her.
And when she appeared reluctant to do so, he made the exchange personal.
That is what transformed an ordinary committee question into a nationally circulated political moment.
The larger debate, however, was far from settled.
The Supreme Court occupies a unique position in American government. Its justices exercise enormous authority, but their decisions are not beyond public criticism.
Legal scholars routinely examine judicial opinions, challenge their reasoning, and question how constitutional doctrines might develop over time.
Indeed, disagreement with the Court is an established part of American legal scholarship.
The difficult question is where criticism ends and personal condemnation begins.
Kennedy’s exchange with Shaw illustrated how quickly that distinction can become a political confrontation.
And Durbin’s subsequent remarks reminded the committee that judicial independence involves more than the language used to describe individual justices.
It also concerns the limits of governmental power.
When a president issues an executive order, when a federal judge blocks an administration’s policy, or when the Supreme Court interprets the Constitution, each institution operates within a system of competing constitutional responsibilities.
That was the broader subject Durbin wanted the committee to examine.
The hearing therefore contained two overlapping arguments.
One concerned the language legal professionals use when discussing judges.
The other concerned how the courts should respond when executive power approaches constitutional boundaries.
Both raised questions about accountability.
Both involved the public’s confidence in American institutions.
And neither could be resolved simply by delivering the sharpest line in a Senate hearing.
As the discussion continued, the attention shifted back toward the constitutional questions before the committee.
But Kennedy’s exchange had already become the moment many viewers would remember.
The professor had been confronted with her own published words.
The senator had challenged her credibility as an educator and legal professional.
And Durbin had redirected the hearing toward the responsibilities of the judiciary in checking executive authority.
The confrontation left an important question for anyone following American legal politics.
Should a law professor’s public criticism of Supreme Court justices be judged by the same standards as courtroom conduct, or should academic freedom protect even language that senators find deeply objectionable?
And when elected officials themselves criticize judges, what standards should apply to them?
Because the credibility of America’s judicial system cannot depend on whether every politician, professor, or citizen agrees with its decisions.
It depends on whether those disagreements can take place without abandoning the constitutional principles that protect the right to challenge authority in the first place.