Sheldon Whitehouse had listened to Ron Johnson defend America’s tax system for nearly twenty minutes when he placed two sheets of paper on the table.
One contained a Senate tax-policy controversy from 2017.
The other displayed an IRS audit comparison.
Whitehouse did not raise his voice.
He did not interrupt.
Instead, he waited until Johnson finished arguing that American businesses needed competitive tax rules and that Washington should stop treating successful entrepreneurs as though wealth itself were a crime.
Then the Rhode Island Democrat leaned toward his microphone.
“Senator Johnson, I want to ask you something.”
Johnson turned toward him.
“Go ahead.”
“When Congress writes a tax preference that saves certain businesses millions of dollars, should the public know who benefits?”
Johnson answered that the effects of tax legislation could be analyzed through public information.
Whitehouse nodded.
“And when the IRS decides which taxpayers to audit, should the public be able to examine whether enforcement is fair?”
“Of course.”
Whitehouse paused.
“Good.”
He unfolded the first page.
It concerned the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act.
Johnson glanced at the document.
Whitehouse continued.

“You demanded changes to the treatment of pass-through businesses before supporting that legislation.”
Johnson nodded.
“I wanted those businesses treated fairly.”
Whitehouse tapped the page.
“And some extremely wealthy business owners later received substantial benefits under the provision.”
Johnson responded that the law applied to qualifying businesses, not merely to billionaires.
Whitehouse acknowledged that.
Then he leaned forward.
“But if the biggest financial benefits flow to people who already possess extraordinary wealth, shouldn’t Congress examine whether the policy achieved what its supporters promised?”
The room became quiet.
Johnson began answering.
“Senator, you’re ignoring the number of small businesses that use pass-through structures.”
Whitehouse nodded.
“Then let’s look at those too.”
He placed the second document on the screen.
The heading read:
WHO GETS AUDITED?
Beneath it were two bars.
Whitehouse looked directly toward Johnson.
“Why should a working family claiming a tax credit face this level of scrutiny while sophisticated high-wealth returns require years of specialized investigation—and Congress keeps fighting over the resources needed to examine them?”
The senator from Wisconsin leaned forward.
“Because you’re comparing different kinds of tax returns.”
Whitehouse nodded.
“That’s a fair objection.”
Then he pointed toward the chart.
“And it’s exactly why I want to discuss the underlying enforcement system rather than hide behind the headline.”
The room fell silent.
The confrontation had begun.
And the most important question was no longer whether billionaires paid taxes.
It was whether the rules governing their taxes, and the resources available to enforce those rules, treated Americans consistently.
The exchange unfolded during a dramatized Senate policy forum examining tax fairness, business incentives, and the Internal Revenue Service.
The political dispute was grounded in real events.
Ron Johnson had played an important role in negotiations surrounding the 2017 tax overhaul.
As Congress prepared the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, Johnson objected to aspects of the proposed treatment of pass-through businesses.
These businesses included partnerships, S corporations, sole proprietorships, and other structures in which certain business income passed through to owners’ individual income tax returns.
Unlike traditional C corporations, they were not generally subject to the same entity-level corporate income tax structure.
Johnson argued that reducing the corporate tax rate without providing comparable relief to pass-through businesses would create an unfair competitive imbalance

He withheld support while pressing for changes.
The final law created a deduction under Section 199A of the Internal Revenue Code.
It allowed qualifying owners to deduct up to 20 percent of certain qualified business income, subject to restrictions and limitations.
The provision affected many kinds of businesses.
Some were small.
Others were extremely large.
And some were owned by very wealthy Americans.
ProPublica later investigated how the tax provision affected affluent business owners and donors.
The investigation found that members of several billionaire families received especially large benefits.
It also examined Johnson’s role in shaping the provision.
Johnson rejected the suggestion that his position had been motivated by donations.
He maintained that he was concerned about fairness for pass-through companies and their ability to compete.
That distinction mattered.
The public record established that Johnson advocated a more favorable tax provision for these businesses.
It established that wealthy business owners benefited significantly.
It did not, by itself, establish a criminal exchange of money for a Senate vote.
Whitehouse understood that limitation.
He also believed it did not end the policy debate.
“Senator,” he began, “let’s distinguish three questions.”
Johnson looked toward him.
“First, was the provision legal?”
The Wisconsin Republican nodded.
“It was enacted by Congress.”
“Second, did it benefit qualifying businesses?”
“Yes.”
“Third, how were those benefits distributed?”
Johnson paused.
Whitehouse continued.
“That’s the question your defense hasn’t answered.”
The senator leaned toward his microphone.
“It benefited businesses of different sizes.”
Whitehouse nodded.
“Correct.”
Then he asked another question.
“How much of the total benefit went to the largest and wealthiest owners?”

Johnson argued that distributional analysis needed to consider the effects on investment, employment, and economic activity.
Whitehouse acknowledged the point.
“But the distribution itself remains relevant.”
He paused.
“Because if Congress describes a tax break as helping small businesses, the public should know how much money reaches small businesses and how much reaches wealthy owners.”
Johnson responded that a large business could also employ thousands of ordinary Americans.
Whitehouse agreed.
“Absolutely.”
Then he leaned forward.
“But jobs supported by a business and tax benefits received by its owners are two different things. We should measure both.”
The room became quiet.
The moderator invited Johnson to explain his position.
He argued that policymakers should consider how taxes affected investment decisions, business formation, competition, and employee compensation.
Some companies could expand when owners retained more after-tax income.
Others might use the savings differently.
The impact depended on the business and the broader economy.
Johnson maintained that pass-through businesses deserved competitive treatment.
Whitehouse acknowledged that tax design involved trade-offs.
Then he challenged whether Congress had adequately examined the benefits flowing to wealthy owners.
The debate was not about whether all pass-through deductions were improper.
They were lawful provisions created by Congress.
It was about whether the legislation was well targeted.
And whether an attractive phrase such as small-business tax relief accurately described the distribution of benefits.
Whitehouse lifted the ProPublica investigation.
“This is why the records matter.”
He paused.
“Because lawmakers can sincerely believe they’re helping businesses.”
Another pause.

“And the final law can still deliver unusually large benefits to people who need the least assistance.”
Johnson challenged that framing.
He argued that wealthy business owners could also be responsible for major capital investments and employment.
Whitehouse acknowledged the economic role of those businesses.
Then he pointed toward the document.
“But the question remains whether the public subsidy, in the form of reduced taxes, is justified by the results.”
The senator from Wisconsin countered that lower taxes were not necessarily a subsidy.
Whitehouse acknowledged that economists and policymakers used different frameworks when describing tax preferences.
Then he returned to the issue of distribution.
Whatever terminology politicians preferred, the provision reduced tax liabilities for qualifying owners.
That effect could be measured.
And Congress could compare it with alternative uses of federal revenue.
The moderator moved to the issue of wealthy donors.
“Senator Whitehouse, are you alleging that Senator Johnson sold his vote?”
Whitehouse answered that he was not presenting evidence sufficient to establish such a crime.
The room quieted.
He continued.
“But the intersection of campaign contributions, lobbying, and legislative benefits deserves transparency.”
Johnson leaned forward.
“Then stop implying that my position was for sale.”
Whitehouse looked toward him.
“Your explanation belongs in the record.”
He paused.
“And so do the benefits received under the legislation.”
Johnson nodded.
“That’s fair.”
Whitehouse continued.
“Then let’s examine both without pretending that a law’s passage settles whether it was good policy.”
The room remained quiet.
The senator turned to the second major issue.
IRS enforcement.
He opened a new folder.
Inside were reports from the Government Accountability Office, the Congressional Research Service, the IRS, and the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse.
The documents examined different aspects of tax administration.
Audit rates.
Staffing.
Enforcement resources.
And the difficulty of reviewing high-income and high-wealth returns.
Whitehouse pointed toward the IRS.
“Senator Johnson, we can pass the best tax rules in the world.”
He paused.
“But if the agency cannot determine whether taxpayers comply with them, the system doesn’t work as intended.”
Johnson responded that the IRS needed accountability and that enforcement should not become harassment.
Whitehouse nodded.
“Agreed.”
The Wisconsin Republican continued.
“Ordinary Americans should not fear an aggressive bureaucracy over an innocent filing mistake.”
Whitehouse acknowledged the concern.
Then he asked whether wealthy taxpayers should face effective scrutiny when their returns involved complicated partnerships, offshore structures, or large-scale transactions.
Johnson answered that the law should apply equally.
Whitehouse leaned forward.
“Then we agree on the standard. Now let’s examine whether the enforcement system has the resources to meet it.”
He displayed the audit chart.
Two bars appeared.
The first represented the lowest-income taxpayers claiming the Earned Income Tax Credit in a particular TRAC comparison.
The second represented millionaires receiving regular audits by IRS revenue agents.
TRAC’s fiscal-year 2022 analysis showed a rate of approximately 1.27 percent for the first group.
For the millionaire group, the relevant field-audit measure was approximately 1.1 percent.
Whitehouse allowed the audience to study the chart.
Then he spoke.
“Look at the comparison.”
Johnson leaned forward.
“Those aren’t identical populations.”
Whitehouse nodded.
“Correct.”
The senator continued.
“And you’re selecting a particular type of audit.”
“Also correct.”
Johnson challenged the implication.
“You can’t use that chart to claim everyone earning a million dollars faces less scrutiny than everyone earning twenty-five thousand.”
Whitehouse agreed.
“That’s not what the chart establishes.”
The room grew quiet.
Then he pointed toward the labels.
“It establishes that, under this specific comparison, low-income EITC taxpayers faced a higher observed audit rate than millionaire taxpayers received regular revenue-agent audits.”
Johnson leaned back.
Whitehouse continued.
“The broader IRS statistics show that very high-income taxpayers often face higher overall audit rates.”
He paused.
“Both statements can be true.”
The moderator nodded.
The distinction was central.
A taxpayer claiming the Earned Income Tax Credit could receive a relatively simple correspondence audit.
Such an examination might focus on documentation for eligibility or qualifying dependents.
A wealthy taxpayer’s return might require extensive examination of partnerships, trusts, complex transactions, and international financial records.
Those cases demanded different levels of expertise and time.
Comparing rates without identifying the audit method could produce misleading conclusions.
Whitehouse acknowledged that complexity.
Then he used it to sharpen his argument.
“If the wealthy returns are harder to audit, that means we need properly trained specialists.”
He paused.
“Not a system that abandons complicated cases because they’re expensive.”
Johnson answered that efficiency and appropriate priorities mattered.
Whitehouse agreed.
“Then let’s evaluate the return on enforcement investment.”
The moderator asked what evidence supported the concern about resource shortages.
Whitehouse cited the Government Accountability Office.
GAO had found opportunities for the IRS to improve its management of high-income and high-wealth audits.
It examined problems involving staffing, training, collaboration, and the targeting of returns.
The report did not imply every wealthy taxpayer was cheating.
Nor did it establish that every complicated return contained hidden income.
But it identified practical difficulties the government needed to address.
Whitehouse opened the document.
“Here’s the issue.”
He paused.
“A high-wealth return can involve numerous entities.”
Another pause.
“Partnership interests.”
“Trusts.”
“Foreign accounts.”
“And transactions that require specialized examination.”
Johnson nodded.
“Which is why government agents need to understand what they’re looking at.”
Whitehouse agreed.
“Exactly.”
Then he asked:
“So what happens when the government cuts the staffing and expertise needed to examine those returns?”
Johnson argued that additional IRS funding did not automatically guarantee improved outcomes.
Whitehouse acknowledged that.
More funding could be used inefficiently.
Poor management could waste resources.
And taxpayer protections remained essential.
But the senator argued that sustained reductions in staffing could make certain complex cases harder to pursue.
That risk was especially important when sophisticated taxpayers could afford lawyers, accountants, and advisers to structure their financial arrangements.
Whitehouse leaned forward.
“A person with a complicated financial structure shouldn’t receive practical immunity simply because investigating the return is expensive.”
The room became quiet.
Johnson responded that nobody should have immunity.
Whitehouse nodded.
“Then the agency must possess the capacity to enforce the law.”
The next discussion concerned the Earned Income Tax Credit.
The EITC was designed to support eligible low- and moderate-income workers and families.
It could reduce taxes owed and generate a refundable credit.
The program had also experienced improper payments.
Those payments could arise from errors, misunderstanding, eligibility disputes, or deliberate fraud.
IRS officials had historically devoted substantial enforcement attention to the credit.
Johnson argued that reducing improper payments was a legitimate government responsibility.
Whitehouse agreed.
“Absolutely.”
Then he made another distinction.
“A low-income family claiming an EITC refund should be required to follow the law.”
He paused.
“And a billionaire using an offshore structure should also be required to follow the law.”
The senator leaned forward.
“The question is whether enforcement resources are allocated fairly and effectively across both kinds of cases.”
Johnson argued that simple correspondence examinations could be completed more quickly than complex high-wealth audits.
Whitehouse acknowledged the operational difference.
Then he challenged the policy response.
“Ease of auditing isn’t the same thing as importance.”
The room fell silent.
He continued.
“Sometimes the hardest cases are exactly the cases the government cannot afford to ignore.”
The senator opened another report.
It concerned the IRS’s criminal investigation division.
In 2026, Whitehouse and several Democratic colleagues had publicly questioned reductions in the IRS’s capacity to investigate sophisticated tax schemes.
They cited cases involving undeclared income and offshore banking arrangements.
One concerned the late billionaire Robert Brockman.
The government had pursued allegations involving billions in unreported income.
The case was associated with major tax recoveries and penalties.
Another involved Credit Suisse and offshore accounts used by wealthy Americans.
The bank had faced U.S. enforcement actions connected to undeclared accounts and tax evasion.
Whitehouse used the examples to demonstrate why financial investigations could require specialized personnel.
But he did not claim that Ron Johnson had participated in either case.
The senator from Wisconsin was not being accused of running an illegal offshore trust.
Nor did supporting a tax deduction establish that he had facilitated a criminal scheme.
The argument concerned the government’s ability to investigate sophisticated financial misconduct wherever it occurred.
Johnson looked toward Whitehouse.
“Senator, you’re discussing criminal tax evasion. That’s different from a lawful pass-through deduction.”
Whitehouse nodded.
“Absolutely.”
The room became quiet.
Then he pointed toward the two documents.
“One is a tax-policy question. The other is an enforcement question. I’m examining how both affect the integrity of the system.”
Johnson continued.
“Then stop treating every wealthy business owner as a tax cheat.”
Whitehouse answered that wealth alone was not evidence of criminal misconduct.
He emphasized that lawful tax planning and unlawful evasion were different.
The distinction was important.
A taxpayer could use deductions expressly permitted by Congress.
An offshore account could be legal when properly disclosed and administered.
A trust could serve legitimate estate-planning or business purposes.
But a structure could become part of unlawful conduct when used to conceal income, misrepresent ownership, or evade taxes in violation of the law.
Whitehouse looked toward Johnson.
“The problem isn’t that a person has a trust. The problem is whether the person uses the structure to break the law—and whether the IRS can detect it.”
The room grew quiet.
The moderator then asked about the federal budget.
Johnson emphasized the national debt and the need to control spending.
He argued that Washington had accumulated enormous obligations and that government agencies should justify their expenditures.
Whitehouse acknowledged the seriousness of federal deficits.
Then he challenged the relationship between tax enforcement and revenue collection.
“If Congress reduces the government’s ability to collect taxes already owed, that’s not automatically fiscal responsibility.”
Johnson responded that federal spending was the central driver of long-term debt problems.
Whitehouse acknowledged that spending decisions mattered.
But he argued that tax compliance was also relevant.
The government had an obligation to collect revenue due under existing law.
If taxpayers successfully evaded taxes, the resulting revenue loss could increase pressure on compliant taxpayers or the federal budget.
Whitehouse leaned toward the microphone.
“You cannot claim to defend fiscal responsibility while refusing to examine whether legally owed taxes are being collected.”
Johnson challenged whether the IRS would use additional resources efficiently.
Whitehouse answered that Congress could require performance measures, audits, reporting, and taxpayer protections.
The senator from Wisconsin insisted that any expansion of enforcement had to avoid unnecessary burdens on small businesses and families.
Whitehouse agreed.
Then he pointed toward the GAO report.
“That’s why oversight matters.”
He paused.
“Not just money.”
“Management.”
“Training.”
“And measurable results.”
The exchange grew more detailed.
Whitehouse described legislative efforts introduced in April 2026 to restore IRS enforcement resources.
The proposal included funding intended to strengthen examinations of wealthy taxpayers and large corporations.
Supporters argued that the investment would improve collection of unpaid taxes.
Critics questioned the cost, management capacity, and potential effects on taxpayers.
The proposal had not, by itself, proved how much additional revenue would be recovered.
That would depend on actual enforcement outcomes.
But it reflected the disagreement between the two approaches.
Whitehouse wanted greater specialized capacity to investigate high-income and high-wealth noncompliance.
Johnson emphasized efficient administration, taxpayer protections, and restraint in expanding federal bureaucracy.
The moderator asked whether the senators could agree on any measurable goals.
Johnson said the IRS should process returns accurately, protect taxpayer rights, and pursue legitimate cases without harassment.
Whitehouse agreed.
Then he added that the agency should also demonstrate it could identify major underpayments in sophisticated returns.
Johnson acknowledged that legitimate tax evasion should be addressed.
Whitehouse nodded.
“Then we’re down to the actual question.”
He reached for the final exhibit.
It contained two comparisons.
The earlier TRAC audit figures.
And the IRS’s more recent official reporting for taxpayers with extremely high incomes.
Whitehouse placed the documents side by side.
One showed the specific FY2022 field-audit comparison.
The other reported that, for tax year 2021, individual taxpayers with at least $10 million in total positive income had an examination coverage rate of 6.6 percent.
The figures used different years and different audit definitions.
They could not be treated as directly interchangeable.
Whitehouse made that explicit.
“Senator Johnson, this is why we don’t compare statistics carelessly.”
He paused.
“One report measures specific audit categories.”
Another pause.
“The other reports examination coverage for a very high-income group.”
Then he pointed toward the documents.
“A serious discussion requires the year, the population, and the method.”
Johnson nodded.
“Agreed.”
The room became quiet.
Whitehouse continued.
“Now I want to ask the question that matters.”
He leaned forward.
“If an ordinary worker makes a mistake on a tax-credit claim, the IRS should apply the law.”
Johnson nodded.
“Yes.”
“If a wealthy individual deliberately hides taxable income through a complex financial arrangement, the IRS should apply the law.”
“Yes.”
“And if the second investigation requires more specialized expertise and time, the government should be able to examine whether it has the resources necessary to do the job.”
Johnson responded that the government needed to demonstrate those resources would be used properly.
Whitehouse nodded.
“That’s fair.”
Then he looked directly toward the Wisconsin senator.
“But do you agree that no taxpayer should become effectively harder to hold accountable simply because the person’s finances are complicated enough to overwhelm the agency investigating them?”
The room fell silent.
Johnson considered the question.
He responded that the tax law should apply to everyone and that enforcement needed to respect due process and taxpayer rights.
Whitehouse nodded.
“Then that’s a standard worth enforcing.”
The moderator announced that time was nearly expired.
Whitehouse turned back to the first document.
The 2017 pass-through deduction.
The legislation Johnson had advocated.
The large benefits received by some wealthy owners.
Then the second document.
IRS enforcement.
Audit resources.
And the practical difficulty of examining complex financial structures.
Whitehouse looked toward the room.
“Here’s what the public deserves to understand.”
He paused.
“Congress writes the rules.”
Another pause.
“Taxpayers use those rules.”
“And the IRS enforces them.”
Then he pointed toward Johnson.
“If the rules disproportionately benefit wealthy people, Congress should examine the policy. If sophisticated taxpayers illegally evade taxes, the IRS should examine the conduct. Neither issue disappears because somebody gives a speech about small business.”
Johnson leaned forward.
“And neither issue gives you the right to smear legitimate business owners.”
Whitehouse nodded.
“Agreed.”
The room became quiet.
He continued.
“That’s why we separate legal tax benefits from illegal tax evasion.”
Another pause.
“And that’s why we separate an argument about fairness from an allegation of criminal wrongdoing.”
The senator then returned to the final chart.
Two bars.
Two types of taxpayers.
Different enforcement methods.
And an unmistakable question about the structure of federal tax administration.
Whitehouse delivered his closing statement.
“Tax fairness isn’t measured by how aggressively we audit the people who can least afford an accountant. It’s measured by whether the law is enforceable across the entire income scale—including the most complicated returns in America.”
Johnson responded that fairness also required protecting taxpayers against excessive government power.
Whitehouse acknowledged that.
“Absolutely.”
Then he added:
“But taxpayer rights and effective enforcement should not be competing principles. A legitimate system needs both.”
The moderator called time.
The exchange concluded.
There was no documented confession from Johnson.
No evidence had been presented that he personally operated an illegal offshore trust.
No new criminal finding had emerged from the pass-through tax provision.
And the audit chart did not prove that every billionaire faced a lower audit probability than every low-income taxpayer.
Those conclusions would go beyond the evidence.
But the debate had identified several documented issues.
Johnson had advocated a significant change to the 2017 pass-through tax provisions.
Some wealthy business owners had received substantial benefits.
Independent researchers had identified disparities in particular IRS audit comparisons.
And federal oversight reports had raised concerns about the agency’s capacity to examine complex high-income returns.
Those issues were connected by a broader policy question.
Was the tax system designed and administered in a way that balanced economic incentives, compliance, revenue collection, and taxpayer rights?
Whitehouse argued that the distribution of tax benefits and the availability of enforcement resources needed more scrutiny.
Johnson defended the business-tax provision and emphasized the danger of burdensome taxation and intrusive enforcement.
Neither position settled the debate on its own.
The relevant evidence included legislative records, tax distribution analyses, enforcement statistics, and actual cases.
After the forum, a reporter approached Whitehouse.
“Senator, did you prove Ron Johnson helped billionaires evade taxes?”
Whitehouse shook his head.
“No.”
The reporter pressed.
“Then what did you establish?”
Whitehouse held up the two documents.
“That a tax law can provide extremely large benefits to wealthy owners and that IRS enforcement faces real challenges involving complicated high-wealth cases.”
He paused.
“Those are different issues.”
Another pause.
“But both deserve examination.”
A second reporter approached Johnson.
“Senator, do you still defend the pass-through provision?”
Johnson answered that he did.
He maintained that the deduction helped businesses compete with corporations and that policymakers should consider the broader economic effects.
The reporter asked whether he supported pursuing wealthy taxpayers who deliberately evaded taxes.
Johnson answered that tax law should be enforced fairly.
He emphasized the importance of preventing the IRS from overreaching.
The contrast remained.
Whitehouse emphasized the risks of insufficient enforcement.
Johnson emphasized the risks of excessive bureaucracy and poorly targeted taxation.
Both pointed toward fairness.
But their preferred policies reflected different understandings of how fairness should be achieved.
The final audit chart became a useful illustration of that disagreement.
It showed that comparisons needed careful definitions.
It showed that certain low-income taxpayers had experienced substantial audit scrutiny.
And it raised questions about how to allocate enforcement resources when complex financial cases could require specialized expertise.
But it did not establish that wealthy Americans were uniformly exempt from IRS scrutiny.
The official 2026 IRS reporting demonstrated that the highest-income groups could face materially higher overall examination rates.
That fact mattered alongside the TRAC analysis.
A responsible assessment required both.
The controversy over Johnson’s 2017 tax position also remained more specific than the opening accusation suggested.
His advocacy helped shape a deduction that benefited many kinds of pass-through businesses.
Some of the largest benefits flowed to wealthy owners.
He maintained that his purpose was competitive treatment for those businesses.
Investigative reporting examined the connection between the legislation and major beneficiaries.
But the available record did not establish a criminal sale of legislative influence.
The policy issue was whether the resulting provision was appropriately designed.
The enforcement issue was whether the IRS possessed sufficient capacity to detect noncompliance under the law Congress had written.
Those questions could be examined without turning political disagreement into unsupported criminal allegations.
And that was where the fictional confrontation ultimately landed.
Whitehouse wanted lawmakers to confront the distribution of tax benefits and the enforcement challenges facing the IRS.
Johnson wanted lawmakers to recognize the economic role of pass-through businesses and protect taxpayers from unnecessary government burdens.
The debate did not produce a new law.
It did not change an individual’s tax liability.
And it did not establish that either senator had committed misconduct.
But it brought a concrete issue into focus.
Fair tax administration requires rules that can be understood, enforcement that can reach complicated cases, and protections that apply consistently to every taxpayer.
The final page of Whitehouse’s folder carried one sentence.
He placed it beside the audit graph before leaving.
“If the tax law applies to everyone, then our ability to enforce it cannot depend on how much money someone has to make the investigation difficult.”
The microphones went dark.
The documents remained.
And the question that mattered was no longer which senator had delivered the sharper attack.
It was whether the tax system’s design and enforcement could be justified against the evidence.