Posted in

“You Don’t Understand the Law!” John Ke.n.n.e.d.y’s Eight Words Confront Jack Sm.i.t.h -ruby

The Senate Judiciary Committee room went completely silent when Jack Sm.i.t.h looked toward Senator John Ke.n.n.e.d.y and delivered a sharp response.

“You don’t understand the law.”

For a moment, the Louisiana Republican said absolutely nothing.

He slowly removed his glasses, placed them beside his microphone, and tapped his yellow notepad twice.

Then he leaned back.

One second passed.

Two.

Three.

The stenographer kept her hands near the keyboard.

Reporters glanced between the former special counsel and the senator who had spent years questioning witnesses with his unmistakable Southern drawl.

Four seconds.

Five.

Six.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y looked toward the stack of papers resting beside his elbow.

Seven.

Eight.

Then he leaned toward his microphone.

His voice remained remarkably calm.

Jack Smith defends Trump probes in Senate hearing filled with GOP insults

“I understand the law. You just weaponized it.”

The words immediately changed the atmosphere.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y had not raised his voice or interrupted the witness.

Instead, he had transformed Sm.i.t.h’s criticism into a direct challenge about prosecutorial authority, constitutional protections, and the limits of federal investigations.

But the Louisiana senator was not finished.

He reached toward a thick manila folder.

And what he removed thirty seconds later would bring the discussion to an entirely different question.

The confrontation had begun during a contentious Senate Judiciary Committee hearing examining Sm.i.t.h’s investigations of President Donald Trump.

Sm.i.t.h had served as special counsel overseeing federal investigations involving Trump’s handling of classified documents and his conduct surrounding the 2020 presidential election.

Those investigations generated criminal charges, major constitutional disputes, and fierce disagreements over the Justice Department’s independence.

Sm.i.t.h maintained that his team had followed the evidence and applicable law without allowing political considerations to determine prosecutorial decisions.

Republican senators questioned whether investigators had exceeded their authority and improperly obtained information involving members of Congress.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y focused on one particularly sensitive issue.

Telephone records.

Not the content of private conversations.

Not recordings of what lawmakers had said.

But records identifying calls, dates, durations, and related information that investigators believed could help reconstruct events surrounding January 6, 2021.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y leaned toward his microphone.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, I’d like to talk about the records your investigators obtained.”

Sm.i.t.h nodded.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y continued.

“Because I think the American people deserve to understand exactly what the federal government was doing.”

The senator opened his notepad.

“Your investigators sought telephone records involving members of the United States Congress. Is that correct?”

Sm.i.t.h explained that investigators had sought records relevant to their examination of efforts to interfere with the certification of the presidential election.

He emphasized that investigators needed evidence concerning communications connected to the events under investigation.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged the explanation.

Then he asked whether the information included records associated with Republican lawmakers.

Sm.i.t.h confirmed that investigative steps had involved records relevant to individuals connected with the events being examined.

But he disputed the suggestion that the investigation had targeted people merely because of their political affiliation.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y lowered his glasses.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, I’m not asking whether you’re a Republican or a Democrat.”

He paused.

“I’m asking whether your investigators obtained telephone records involving members of Congress.”

Sm.i.t.h defended the investigative basis for seeking the information.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y nodded.

“Then let’s talk about the Constitution.”

He turned a page.

The senator pointed toward the Speech or Debate Clause, a constitutional protection designed to preserve legislative independence.

Article I, Section 6 provides protections against questioning members of Congress elsewhere for speech or debate in either chamber.

The provision has long generated disputes about the limits of executive branch investigations involving congressional activities.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y argued that investigators needed to be especially careful when seeking information involving lawmakers performing their constitutional responsibilities.

Sm.i.t.h maintained that his team had acted within lawful investigative authority and had sought information relevant to potential criminal conduct.

The difference between those positions became the central issue.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y questioned whether obtaining records associated with legislators risked exposing protected legislative activity.

Sm.i.t.h responded that the legal analysis depended on the nature of the information sought and the purposes of the investigation.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged that constitutional protections required careful interpretation.

Then he asked whether his investigators had evaluated those protections before seeking the records.

Sm.i.t.h defended his team’s legal review and maintained that the investigative steps were properly authorized.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y leaned forward.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, the question isn’t whether your lawyers believed they had authority.”

He paused.

“The question is whether that authority had constitutional limits.”

Sm.i.t.h responded that federal investigators operated under legal requirements and judicial procedures governing access to records.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y nodded.

“Of course they do.”

Then his voice sharpened.

“But following a procedure doesn’t automatically answer every constitutional question.”

The room grew quieter.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y’s argument focused on the distinction between obtaining judicial authorization and establishing that an investigative step complied with all applicable constitutional protections.

Sm.i.t.h maintained that the records had been relevant to a lawful criminal investigation.

He emphasized that the inquiry concerned efforts to obstruct the certification of the election, not ordinary congressional disagreement.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged that investigators could examine criminal conduct.

But he insisted that lawful investigative objectives did not eliminate protections associated with the legislative branch.

The senator turned another page.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, members of Congress are supposed to be able to perform their constitutional duties without intimidation from the executive branch.”

Sm.i.t.h agreed that the separation of powers was fundamental.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y nodded.

“Then we’re starting from the same Constitution.”

He pointed toward the witness.

“But we may not be reading the same limits into it.”

The discussion became more intense when Ke.n.n.e.d.y asked whether investigators had considered the possibility of obtaining information unrelated to the alleged criminal conduct.

Sm.i.t.h responded that investigative requests were intended to gather relevant records and corroborate information from other sources.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged the stated purpose.

Then he asked what procedures had been used to distinguish protected legislative activity from communications that might legitimately become evidence.

Sm.i.t.h defended the investigation’s legal framework.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y pressed again.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, how did you ensure the federal government wasn’t intruding into the constitutional responsibilities of Congress?”

The question brought the room to another pause.

Sm.i.t.h responded that investigators had not treated congressional membership as a reason to pursue anyone and had operated under established legal standards.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y remained focused.

He wanted an explanation of the procedures, not simply reassurance about the team’s intentions.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, intentions are wonderful things.”

He paused.

“But constitutional rights don’t depend entirely on whether a prosecutor believes he’s doing the right thing.”

Several senators looked toward the witness table.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y continued.

“That’s why we have rules. That’s why we have courts. And that’s why we have constitutional protections.”

Sm.i.t.h defended the distinction between political activity and conduct potentially relevant to a criminal investigation.

He emphasized that prosecutors were required to investigate evidence without giving individuals immunity from scrutiny solely because they held public office.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged that elected officials were not automatically immune from criminal investigation.

But he argued that the Constitution created specific protections for legislative functions.

“Nobody’s saying a senator gets a free pass to commit a crime.”

He tapped his notepad.

“I’m saying the government has to respect the Constitution while investigating one.”

The exchange continued as Sm.i.t.h defended the investigative decisions made by his office.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y questioned the scope of the records sought and whether investigators had adequately considered the rights of legislators whose information might be collected.

Their disagreement was substantial.

Sm.i.t.h argued that evidence gathering had been tied to the investigation’s lawful objectives.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y maintained that the Senate needed a clearer account of how investigators evaluated constitutional limits before pursuing information involving lawmakers.

Then the exchange reached its sharpest point.

Sm.i.t.h challenged Ke.n.n.e.d.y’s interpretation of the legal issues.

“You don’t understand the law.”

The words landed across the hearing room.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y removed his glasses.

He set them beside the microphone.

Then he tapped his notepad twice.

For eight full seconds, he said nothing.

When he finally spoke, his voice carried the familiar rhythm of a Louisiana courtroom lawyer.

“I understand the law. You just weaponized it.”

Sm.i.t.h rejected the accusation.

He maintained that his investigations were based on evidence and law, not a political mission to target Republicans.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged the denial.

Then he looked toward the manila folder.

“Well, Mr. Sm.i.t.h, I’ve got something here I’d like you to explain.”

He reached inside.

For several seconds, the senator searched through the papers.

Then he removed a document and held it beside his microphone.

It concerned the legal authorization investigators relied upon when seeking telephone records.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y placed the page on the desk.

“Now, this is the part I want the American people to understand.”

He pointed toward the document.

“Investigators don’t simply get to collect whatever information they want because they believe their case is important.”

Sm.i.t.h responded that investigators were required to follow applicable laws and obtain necessary authorization.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y nodded.

“Exactly.”

He turned the page.

“And those authorizations need to be examined against the constitutional rights involved.”

The senator’s question became more specific.

If the government sought telephone records involving legislators, how had the special counsel’s office determined which information could lawfully be obtained?

Sm.i.t.h maintained that his team had relied on legal processes appropriate to the records being sought.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y questioned whether those processes sufficiently addressed the Speech or Debate Clause.

The distinction mattered.

Telephone toll records generally identify connections between numbers without revealing the contents of conversations.

But disputes can arise when records potentially expose relationships or activities associated with protected legislative functions.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y argued that investigators needed to establish clear boundaries before collecting information implicating congressional independence.

Sm.i.t.h maintained that the records had been sought for legitimate investigative purposes and were not designed to uncover protected legislative deliberations.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged the distinction between content and metadata.

Then he returned to his central concern.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, if the information is legally available, explain the authority.”

He pointed toward the paper.

“If it’s constitutionally protected, explain the safeguard.”

The room quieted.

“And if there’s uncertainty, don’t pretend the Constitution disappears just because a prosecutor wants to move faster.”

Sm.i.t.h responded that investigators routinely faced complicated constitutional questions and that their actions had been guided by legal review.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y nodded.

“Then let’s examine the review.”

He opened another section of the folder.

The document concerned the difference between records obtained through judicial authorization and information protected by constitutional privilege.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y emphasized that constitutional protections could require analysis beyond ordinary evidentiary relevance.

A document might be useful to investigators without necessarily being accessible under every circumstance.

Likewise, a subpoena might satisfy certain procedural requirements while still facing a separate constitutional challenge.

Sm.i.t.h maintained that those distinctions had been considered in the investigation.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y challenged him to explain how.

“What did your office do to protect information that might involve legitimate legislative activity?”

Sm.i.t.h reiterated that investigators had sought records relevant to potential misconduct and had relied on established legal procedures.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y leaned forward.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, you’re telling us what you believed.”

He paused.

“I’m asking what safeguards you used.”

The chairman allowed the exchange to continue.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y placed the document beside his notepad.

Then he turned toward the larger question of prosecutorial power.

Federal prosecutors possessed substantial authority.

They could seek subpoenas, gather evidence, interview witnesses, and request court orders under applicable law.

Those powers were necessary to investigate criminal conduct.

But Ke.n.n.e.d.y argued that the same powers required meaningful checks when investigations implicated constitutionally protected government functions.

Picture background

Sm.i.t.h responded that the Justice Department was obligated to investigate possible crimes regardless of political affiliation.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged that responsibility.

“That’s right.”

He paused.

“And the Constitution doesn’t become optional just because the investigation involves serious allegations.”

Sm.i.t.h maintained that his office had not pursued its investigations for political reasons.

He emphasized that the evidence had guided prosecutorial decisions.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y nodded.

“But when investigators use the power of the federal government, the public gets to ask how that power was used.”

The senator placed both hands on the desk.

“That’s not harassment. That’s oversight.”

The discussion turned toward the relationship between the executive and legislative branches.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y argued that congressional independence depended on protections preventing executive officials from improperly intruding into legislative activities.

Sm.i.t.h maintained that those protections did not create blanket immunity for communications potentially relevant to criminal conduct.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged the distinction.

Then he asked where the boundary had been drawn in the investigation.

The disagreement remained unresolved.

Both men emphasized the importance of constitutional law.

They differed over whether the investigative procedures adequately protected congressional privileges.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y returned to the document from his folder.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, this is what I want the committee to examine.”

He tapped the paper.

“Not whether you dislike Donald Trump.”

He paused.

“Not whether somebody thinks your prosecutions were politically popular.”

Then he looked directly toward Sm.i.t.h.

“I want to know whether the federal government respected the legal boundaries protecting Congress.”

Sm.i.t.h responded that his team had followed the law and had not pursued anyone solely because of political beliefs or affiliations.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged the position.

But he emphasized that congressional oversight required examining the records supporting those assurances.

He asked that the relevant legal authorizations and procedures receive careful scrutiny.

The chairman indicated that the hearing needed to continue with other senators’ questions.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y glanced toward the clock.

Then he returned to his notes.

There was one final question.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, you’ve spent your career as a prosecutor.”

Sm.i.t.h acknowledged his professional experience.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y continued.

“You know how powerful a subpoena can be.”

He paused.

“You know what happens when the federal government starts gathering information about somebody.”

The room became quiet.

“And you know that our constitutional system was designed to place limits on that power.”

Sm.i.t.h responded that he understood those limits and had sought to operate within them.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y looked directly toward the witness.

Then he asked the question that brought the confrontation back to its beginning.

“Mr. Sm.i.t.h, if your investigation respected every constitutional safeguard, will you identify the precise legal authority and the protections your office used before obtaining records involving members of Congress?”

For several seconds, the room remained still.

Sm.i.t.h maintained that his office’s actions had been lawful and that the investigative record supported the decisions his team made.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y acknowledged the answer.

Then he placed the document back inside the manila folder.

“That’s the record this committee needs to examine.”

He put on his glasses.

The confrontation had begun with a dispute about legal knowledge.

It ended with a demand for a specific explanation of investigative authority and constitutional safeguards.

Sm.i.t.h continued defending the legality of his work and rejected allegations that his office had been motivated by partisan considerations.

Ke.n.n.e.d.y maintained that congressional oversight should examine whether prosecutors had respected the Constitution when seeking records involving legislators.

Neither a prosecutor’s assurance nor a senator’s accusation could settle that legal dispute on its own.

The answer depended on the applicable law, the nature of the records, and the procedures investigators followed.

The manila folder had brought those questions into focus.

And the eight-word response remained the defining challenge of the exchange.

“I understand the law. You just weaponized it.”

The allegation was fiercely disputed.

But the question left at the center of the hearing was one that extended beyond either man.

Jack Smith's Closing Argument | The New Yorker

When federal investigators pursue evidence involving members of Congress, what specific safeguards ensure that the government’s investigative power remains within the limits of the Constitution?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *